JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: As many of you know, I’ve spent quite some time this past month clearing out my Dad’s house now he’s moved into a senior living center. I won’t go into the mountains of trash and van loads of donations generated by two neat people who weren’t into “stuff” - we’ve discussed the trials and tribulations of emptying a house someone’s lived in for a quarter century before.
No, what I want to talk about is the furniture. My dad took a one bedroom apartment’s worth with him, of course, and we had items that had long been designated as heading for one or another child (marked with a piece of masking tape underneath, natch.) But there was so much more. The guest bed, and the loveseat, and the little 1930s table my mom kept plants on. The huge bookcase/desk/étagère/storage units my folks had in their den, which were both ugly AND massively heavy. There was the Queen Anne dining set in perfect condition, so out of style now the appraiser said it wasn't worth the effort for him to haul it away. (I’m hoping someone in a Syracuse area Goodwill will see it and be overjoyed at her good luck.)
One of my brothers stepped up and took the enormous cherry breakfront, and fortunately, I have two kids now living in unfurnished rentals, so they’re happy to take the unfashionable 90’s sofa and the double bed. The plant table is now holding a TV in Youngest’s apartment, and the brass lamps will help light up the Sailor’s house.
It made me look at my own furniture, with an eye to what my kids and grandkids might think. I passed beyond the student digs/young married housing stage where most of my stuff was found on the street during Large Item Pick Up Day, or given to me by parents when they upgraded. (I’m doing this now - Youngest got two mismatched wing chairs, which I replaced with my mother’s sleek midcentury arm chairs - back in fashion!) I have The Big Investment Pieces, like the dining table that seats 14 (we have two sets of chairs for it) and the china hutch, which I already know is out of fashion, but I’m not going to the trouble of replacing it. I have the Sensible Buy items, like two Pottery barn sofas, the pine coffee table, and the rugs.
And have quite a few items that just came to me in various ways. A loveseat from a friend moving to Colorado. (We were going to sell it, but it was just too comfortable.) Bookcases whose provenances I can’t even remember. Bits and pieces from auctions and yard sales and fundraisers. Family pieces from my grandmother, inherited from her grandparents and beyond: an original Morris chair, Victorian beds from the 1850s, a set of hand-caned cherry chairs.
I tell my kids the stories of the family items, but I realize even that might not be enough to save them once I’ve departed for another home (either nursing or heavenly.) Some things I treasure will wind up in a Goodwill store or on Craigslist, and some things I think are beautiful will cause my grandkids to roll their eyes. Wait until matching dining chairs and tables in brown wood come back! I can hear them wail, “Granny, why didn’t you save that Queen Anne set!?!”
How about you, Reds? Do you have family heirlooms or hand-me-downs? Do you have pieces the kids will fight over, and ones they’ll flip a coin to see who has to take to the dump?
HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: We have so many wonderful things--gorgeous art, and beautiful heirloom china. Antique clocks. SIlverware, so very elegant. A chair from 1811, incredible. No one will want any of it, I fear. I think about it sometimes, but for now I am happy that it makes us happy, and later, after our wills are read, someone will have to deal with it, and I hope they are happy, too.
(I’ll never forget when a relative was given the task of organizing the round robin choice of another relative’s heirlooms. She had everything laid out in the living room, and all of us, in order of age, came in one at a time to choose one thing I was second, and I remember looking around the room, and saying, Oh, I was hoping for the silver candlesticks, or the silver teapot, but I don't see them.
There was a beat of silence.
Oh, the relative said. You like silver? We didn’t think any of you would, so we didn't include it.
IT WAS ALL HIDDEN IN ANOTHER ROOM.)
HALLIE EPHRON: I can count on one hand the objects I ‘inherited.’ A coffee table and a silver-plated platter. My parents downsized and downsized and… died.
The rest of our stuff my husband and I acquired, most of it at yard sales and auctions. Forty years of mismatched tables, chairs, lamps, art work, aging oriental rugs… Like Julia’s Queen Anne dining set, ours is oak Victorian. Very out of fashion. Too bad I didn’t see the beauty of Mid-Century Modern before it got popular.
Sometimes I sit in my living room and look around and play What Would I Take With Me. I imagine the two-bedroom apartment I’ll one day move into. No leaves to rake. No roof to leak. No heating system to repair. Hopefully no Covid. I think I can walk away from most everything in my house except for some of the art and some dishes I’m particularly fond of. Our brass double bed. Some cobalt Depression glass.
Our kids are already up to their gills in possessions so I hope it doesn’t fall to them to deal with all of it. Julia, I am I awe.
JULIA: And this was after helping two friends clear out their houses before their cross-country moves!
LUCY BURDETTE: Oh my sister and I were discussing a family heirloom today. (LOL) We shared a room for most of our early to teenage lives and slept in matching maple twin beds. One of them is in our son’s room (now mostly for guests) and she found hers in their storage shed. We’d love for someone to appreciate them but I fear it’s mostly sentimental attachment. The kids have pretty much told us what they’re interested in--a rattan porch set, the silver that belonged to my parents, maybe the china. And we do have nice art, mostly watercolors and local artists. I better get busy with my masking tape labels.
RHYS BOWEN: Our kids mantra is ‘don’t you dare die and leave us with all this stuff’ .
We have a house full of antiques from John’s family. Some are really lovely. The Queen Anne desk (real 1700s) is valuable. Also Georgian card table. We have Chinese plates, some good art and Victorian music box. Pieces of Victorian silver. My collection of National dolls in costume etc etc. lots of stuff! I’m not sure what the kids will want. Some things can be donated to a museum. And some should sell well at auction. I gather Chinese antiques are desirable.
I should be decluttering now, I know!
DEBORAH CROMBIE: We have a couple of things that my daughter has always coveted. One is the chaise longue that belonged to my mom, and is now, reupholstered for the umpteenth time, in my office. The other is a painted Chinese secretary that belonged to a great aunt. But her taste is now so modern and minimalist that I don't know what she'd do with them.
Our dining room furniture is gorgeous, Stickley-esque Drexel, and we also have a huge custom-built Welsh dresser. And so much china! And my mom's sterling, which I know my daughter will want. Most everything else is a comfortable hodge-podge with a few antiques thrown in. I doubt she'll want my enormous collection of London Transport posters, although she might find a favorite few. I shudder to think about downsizing…
JENN MCKINLAY: My parents were big on stuff. Mom, the librarian, loved books and dad was an artist, so it was a cluttered existence. They were so big on stuff that I am anti-stuff. My house is small, my stuff is minimal and I love it this way. I do have one grandmother’s silver, the other grandmother’s Windsor chair, a lot of art, many books, and my precious wedding china, but otherwise I don’t own much of anything except for plants and pets and utilitarian furniture. My children love this about me — as they should.
JULIA: Jenn, I promise, they will bless you. My sister and I were so grateful our mom had started "Swedish Death Cleaning" before she unexpectedly passed away, and that dad had been cleaning out and giving away so much of her stuff. On the other hand, if I go toes up early, I've told the kids to take what they want and then torch the place. Making an insurance claim will be easier than cleaning out this old house.
How about you, dear readers? What do you have that might be treasures or trials?