Saturday, June 22, 2024

What We're Writing Week: Julia Doodles

JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: May was a month of travel, travel, travel for me and not a lot of writing, writing, writing as a result. I was in DC to help my sister with some stuff, in Colorado to celebrate a dear friend's landmark birthday, and, importantly for this post, in East Hampton, where I joined in an artists' retreat at my friend Shari Goddard Shambaugh's house.

Shari is a painter, one of those seemingly effortless hostesses, and someone who draws all sorts of interesting and creative people into her orbit. I was there with Gail Donovan, who writes middle-grade fiction, and artist Meredith Cough, another painter. 

We worked, we ate really well (another one of Shari's talents) we talked for hours every evening and we made a pilgrimage to see the Jackson Pollock/Lee Krasner House, where we got to put on disposable booties and walk ON the floor of Pollock's studio, which was a lot like walking on one of his paintings. 


The visual artists went out for several plein air sessions, while Gail and I wrote. The Shambaughs live in the historic rectory of St. Luke's Church, which was built in the days when the residents were expected to have a half dozen kids and an attic full of servants. There was plenty of room for everyone.

Part of the pleasure of the retreat was hashing out ideas and issues with each other. I had been expressing my frustration at feeling stuck near the very end of the book - the big action set piece and climax of the mystery/thriller plot. These scenes are never easy for me, because moving characters through space and having them do action-y stuff like run, jump, shoot, fight - and keeping it all flowing and easy for the reader to visualize - is tough. (Sometimes I wish I could write 300 pages of my characters just talking. I'd be done in a month.)

This time, it was even more difficult than usual, because the denouement takes place in a real-world location and I've managed to collect six major characters and three side characters, all of whom do things, make decisions, affect the action, etc. Yes, I know I'm an idiot.

Part of the issue, as I explained it to the group, was having TOO much in my head - I had outlined the big strokes of the scene, but breaking that down into the granular moment-by-moment had me snarled and overwhelmed.

Shari suggested I try drawing a rough map of where the action takes place, and, using a different colored dot for each character, move them moment by moment through the scene. I'm not much of an artist (ie, not at all) but I figured I'd give it a try. She handed me a sheaf of sketch paper and a box of colored pencils and off I went to my room.

Reader, it was a breakthrough! I didn't cut out dots (I honestly figured I'd lose them at the first sneeze) and instead used the first letter of the characters names, each with its own color. Within sketching out the first two pages, I realized what had kept me jammed up was holding all the decisions each major player had to make in my head. Drawing the who-what- when-where, instead of thinking or even outlining, enabled me to break down the scene into it's component beats: decision -> action-> results-> next decision-> next action, etc., etc.


I spent all afternoon sketching (badly) and marking up the pages with notes, working my way through the scene and eventually positioning my characters for the second half of the climax, where they get spotlighted in their own individual/couple moments. 

 

When I finished, I felt as if a 500 pound rock has been lifted off my shoulders. Illustrating the events, rough as it was, turned out to be a terrific technique for busting up that mental logjam. I've been using and expanding on the original sketches since then (well, since getting home from Colorado at the end of May,) much to the pleasure of my cat Neko, who really, really likes stretching out on sketching paper. 



Dear readers, have you tried a new way of solving an old problem?

75 comments:

  1. How wonderful that your friend's suggestion worked so well for you . . . .
    It always amazes me when someone can see a problem from a different perspective and suggest the very thing that solves it. And yet it never seems to occur to me to look for a new solution to a problem and I always seem to end up solving them in the old [familiar] way . . . .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Joan, it never would have occurred to me on my own, because I use words, period, to solve my problems. Shari is a visual person, so that's the way she went, much to my benefit.

      Delete
  2. How ingenious! So happy this suggestion worked for you. Looking forward to reading the book.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What a great way to change modalities, Julia. I'm so happy it helped you break the logjam! I love that kind of retreat, which I haven't been on since before the pandemic began (Ramona used to organize several of us, including Annette, sniff...).

    Based on something Hallie said once (maybe in a Crime Bake master class?), I sometimes draw a relationship map with all the important characters around the outside, the victim in the middle, and arrows leading them to each other, looking for the arrows pointing in both directions. I'm sure explaining it that way doesn't make sense, but it helps me figure out the relationships. Depending on the book, it can help me see which of the suspects is the true bad guy (that is, the killer).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Edith, as you described the drawing process Maisie Dobbs’ case maps came to mind. Wondering if Jacqueline Winspear uses her character’s technique in writing. Elisabeth

      Delete
    2. That's an interesting technique I'd like to try, Edith. Kind of like a mind map, but for the characters.

      Delete
    3. I"ve done a sort of similar mind map, Edith, but had forgotten about that technique. Thanks for the reminder!

      Delete
  4. Julia, so glad the logjam is unjammed!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not just any anonymous, Elisabeth anonymous.

      Delete
  5. First, I'll take a book of Clare and Russ and Kevin and Hadley talking -- those couples have so much to say. (Yes, I like to think of Kevin and Hadley as a couple.)

    Two, yes: I was stuck in a bad business relationship UNTIL I sat down and, spontaneously, found myself writing on the back of an envelope 'I want out'. That's when I realized I wanted out and needed to GEt out. And I did. (The new way was actually WRITING DOWN on paper what I was thinking in my head; such a relief.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Also, congrats for breaking the logjam, Julia! I am so pleased for you (and your devoted readers eagerly waiting...)

      Delete
    2. Thanks, Amanda. And you're absolutely supposed to think of Kevin and Hadley as a couple!

      Delete
  6. Congrats Julia. Have you tried writing those scenes now?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, and I've been able to move through the complicated "choreography." It turned out the issue was keeping it all in my head running simultaneously - having to break it into beats enabled me to focus on each decision-action-result cycle.

      Delete
    2. Yay!! I can't tell you how much I want to read this!

      Delete
  7. Weren't we talking about switching gears with Jenn lately? Do you think forcing yourself to put your ideas into a visual and manipulable form made your brain form new synapses, Julia?

    When my two younger kids were in kindergarten and first grade (and probably yours, too), the latest thing was to teach math/counting using manipulative objects, things they could physically move and count. It seemed to cement the ideas in their minds so much more clearly than when the numbers were in the abstract, or even printed on a page. That physical engagement had an edge over the kind of learning we did as children, giving their brains a "handle" or a visual representation of the problem. Sounds like your dot/drawing exercise was a similar way through your mind, Julia.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. An author I adore, Jennifer Crusie, uses collages for the early character, setting and plotting work. (Google to see some - they're amazing.) But I've never seen the real utility to them. I still don't think I'd use the technique - the starting stuff comes easily to me - but I'll definitely keep an eye out for more visual arts techniques of thinking through problem points.

      Delete
  8. This is fascinating. And hoping to hear - later- how it all worked out for the book.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'm so glad you had a breakthrough, Julia. I sometimes make difficult decisions (not just about writing) by drawing up lists of pros and cons and studying them, which is not very original but effective for me. But I've never tried drawing anything, in part because I can barely draw a stick man. You make me think I should try it sometime! Good luck!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I do decision trees that serves as pro and con lists, Kim; my character goes into the scary basement and a, b, and c happens, or she stays out and calls for help and x, y, and z happens. It's a good plotting technique for me.

      Delete
  10. Julia, any time I hear that you're making progress on the next book, I do a little happy dance.

    I, too, struggle with the action scenes. For what it's worth, I think you do them very well, and I often go back and re-read those scenes for inspiration. I love this idea of mapping out the characters locations and movements. Currently, I'm still mired in the middle, but once I get to the climax, I'll have to give it a try.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I never question your action scenes, Annette! And I loved your latest book! WHAT COMES AROUND is great!

      Delete
    2. I agree with Judy, Annette, you do wonderful action scenes. Maybe those of us who have to wrestle with them take more time to really make sure they work.

      Delete
    3. Count me in, too, as a reader who thinks you have an unquestionable talent for action scenes, Annette. Helpless should be required reading for writers wanting to take their action scenes to the next level.

      Delete
    4. Judy, Julia, and Kathy, you all are making me blush. Thank you. It's something I'm always terribly insecure about.

      Delete
  11. Wonderful news! I hope this makes the actual writing much, much easier.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This approach is so interesting. All this time you have been trying to visualize the scene. It is just the best coincidence in the world that you were visiting a visual artist whose suggestion broke you out of your wheel. Just amazing and wonderful. Keep us posted on your progress.

    I would say that having a good psychologist or psychiatrist to help you find a different way of thinking about life problems, how to approach recurring issues, how to strategize for your own better mental health, is similar to changing an artistic approach. At least once a week, I thank my lucky stars for the good life he showed me I could make.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's an interesting point, Judy. I did therapy back in '15-'16, and it definitely helped me rewire some of my actions and responses in concrete and helpful ways.

      Delete
  13. Julia, I'm very happy for you! And for me, as a past and future reader. (Selden)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Action scene choreography is a challenge for me, too. The paper map is an easy way to get a tabletop map. That's a great idea. It reminded me of the 3D tabletop maps in the movies. Then again, who has the table space to dedicate to that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, I do have an enormous dining table that's only used a few times a year, Rhonda. Hmm....

      Delete
  15. Julia, I am so happy for you and for all of US that you learned a new way of working it out! As far as I am concerned however, I would be just as happy to read your 300 pages of conversation - as long as it was clear who was saying what. When I read action scenes, like what you have described, I can only imagine what all you went through to get the choreography just right. Then I try to work it out, more than picturing it in my mind, so I can make sense of what is happening. Sometimes I am not as successful as I would wish to be.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Judi, if you can't work it out, that's on us, not on you. The reader should be able to picture and understand everything gong on in an action scene.

      Delete
  16. Good for you! My arty daughter left behind a pantry full of art supplies, so I use a huge sketchpad and handful of sharpies for floorplans, street maps, and action scenes. It works for me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I may need to invest in some similar supplies, Margaret!

      Delete
  17. Would be interested in hearing how the other JRW handle their endings too.
    Sometimes I get confused especially if it involves a lot of people toward the end. One thing that helps me as a reader (especially if there are a lot of characters) is to write down their name and a one word note about them. If I put down the book for a bit and come back it is helpful to be reminded about the characters.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm wondering if I ought to suggest a character list at the beginning for this book, Anon. Remember back when those were common? I loved them.

      Delete
    2. I do not like character lists, as a reader. I have read all of your published books and I do not think that you need this. I would rather find out about the characters while I am reading. Part of a book’s charm is watching someone grow, learn and maybe, change. We can find out about the character in the book!

      Delete
    3. Oh, I love character lists, too. As I get more forgetful in my older years, having a character list to refer back to is much appreciated.

      Delete
  18. Hank Phillippi RyanJune 22, 2024 at 9:39 AM

    What a gorgeous house, and what a gorgeous solution! But —I keep expanding the screen to try to read your notes, —and can’t. I guess I’ll just have to wait for the real thing! Hooray that it is on the way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hahaha, Hank! Me too--I want to read Julia's notes!

      Delete
    2. Hank, I can barely read my notes full-sized and next to me. When I'm jotting quickly, I have the world's worst handwriting.

      Delete
    3. Hank, that's so funny. I thought about trying to do that and couldn't do it. I didn't want to take a chance of knowing ahead what was going to happen, especially near the end of the book.

      Delete
  19. From Diana: What a gorgeous house! I would have loved to visit the rectory, Julia. Hooray that the book is on the way! I look forward to reading your book.

    That is a gorgeous solution. It does not matter if you “can draw”✍🏻 as long as you know what you are drawing, right? Though I would never claim to be an artist, I still draw pictures. I have been keeping a book journal and I would draw little things to make my homemade journal look pretty.

    Did I ever try a new solution for an Old problem? Math became a struggle for me once I hit my teenage years. I remember trying an experience to see if it would help with my math skills. I decided to try a jigsaw puzzle and focus my brain on putting together all of the pieces.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Doing a jigsaw is one of those activities that can release the creative part of your brain, Diana. Like knitting, or needlepoint or woodworking - you have to keep your head in the game, but it's a different part of your head, as it were.

      Delete
  20. This is brilliant, Julia. I use a whiteboard and draw lines between characters, actions to show who does what and when

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I may have to try that, Rhys - at least my cat wouldn't be able to obscure what I've done!

      Delete
  21. This isn’t an answer to the question Julia posed, but was inspired by her post. There will be an exhibit of Lee Krasner’s work in Ogunquit, Maine at the Museum of American Art from August 1 to November 17. https://ogunquitmuseum.org/exhibition/krasner/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, that's exciting to know, Pat! I'll have to get my friends together and make a day of it.

      Delete
  22. This is sort of like finding a new route for driving to a place that’s always annoying to get to because of traffic. I used to have a job that required me to drive around the state. There were places I really hated going to because there were always traffic jams right near my destination. I decided to look for alternate routes. This was long before GPS. I bought atlases of the two counties I went to most frequently, and studied them. I think I now know every back road in Fairfield County and New Haven County!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think all the techniques everyone is mentioning today are like atlases for writers, DebRo.

      Delete
  23. If this technique breaks your log jammed finale then I suggest you purchase several different sizes of sketch books and multiple sets of colored pencils for the next book. Go, Julia, go!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right? An excuse to buy art supplies! That's a win-win.

      Delete
  24. Nothing like a visual to explain things. I bet your brain grew two sizes after that!

    ReplyDelete
  25. Storytellers often draw storyboards to help develop a story, which can give a new perspective. <3
    -- Storyteller Mary

    ReplyDelete
  26. Let me add my congratulations to the others on finding a new way to get through your brain jam!

    In terms of finding a new way to solve an old problem, I think the “woman way” as my husband would call it - talking it out with a friend (or many times with a therapist) - is my best strategy. Getting another perspective is what is usually needed. And we women are usually very intuitive and good at communicating so that works for me. I don’t think that would have worked for you in this situation, though, Julia! Unless you had your friends represent your characters! However it happened for you, I am very happy that you are happy with the outcome. — Pat S

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pat, I'm definitely an external processor - I've driven more than one family member crazy by talking through my entire thought process OUT LOUD before coming to a conclusion. It has to be out of my head in order to move forward, and this gave me another way of pulling everything out of my brain and onto the page.

      Delete
  27. FANTASTIC!!! Julia, I am so glad you've found a way to sort it all out. I suppose this is why artists need other artists like the air we breathe. Brilliant.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I find it fascinating that the visual artist was able to imagine a way for the writing artist to combine the two art forms into a successful solution. And, of course, kudos to you, Julia, for listening to Shari and giving it a try. I'm so glad it worked out. I have to say that I think your action scenes are always top-notch, so well staged (Oh, I just brought another art form into the mix, hahaha). But seriously, your action scenes do always thrill me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Staging is a good word, Kathy, because part of my approach is mentally blocking my "actors" as they move through the scene.

      Delete
  29. This is great! I was able to zoom in and see the character names in the scene and was soooo happy to see a couple of them in there. Happy writing and we are all looking forward to the book.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I love when a friend helps me think outside of my box! I ask soooooo looking forward to your next book

    ReplyDelete
  31. Julia, your action scenes are always terrific, and I'm sure this one will be, too. I love that the visual prompt helped you. (There is nothing more fun than art supplies!) Scenes with more than two or three characters are always a challenge for me, but especially action scenes. I am definitely going to try your technique for the big climax in my book!

    ReplyDelete
  32. Wow! What a great way to switch things mentally and have a new approach! Wonderful that it worked. This group is such an inspiration and education about writing, reading, and life in general!
    (Heather S)

    ReplyDelete