JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: It started out innocently enough, wit a few articles about this new "Artificial Intelligence" thing and a few more articles wherein pundits predicted we'd all be living in the Terminator Universe soon, crushed under the chrome-plated jackboot of our robot overlords.
But it turns out AI is far, far more annoying than killer machines.
Everywhere I turn, another company is eager to thrust it's AI chatbot/ tools/ research aids upon me. It started when I realized every time I logged in to my health insurance website, this annoying little seal pops up and asks me what I'm doing on every. Single. Page. And you can't get rid of it! The first thing everyone did back in the day was toss Microsoft's Clippy in the trash, what makes you think we want another version?
Then, of course, I had Google decide, in its infinite wisdom, that I needed "AI summaries" of every search I made. I cannot convey to you how deeply irritating I find this. It's like being forced to watch someone acting out their kink in public. My friend, I know there are people who like licking boots, but I don't need to clap eyes on it. And I know there are people who want instant information from untrustworthy, error-prone Large Language Models, but I want to click on websites and judge the information myself.
Recently, my professorial Zoom account "upgraded," and I was confronted with a slightly changed dashboard (vexing, but not worth more than an eyeroll) and a new title: I was no longer using Zoom, but Zoom Workplace. What the heck is Zoom Workplace, you ask? According to the company, it "brings communication, employee engagement, spaces, and productivity solutions together on a single platform with Zoom AI Companion capabilities woven throughout."
Really Zoom? I know I'm getting old, but do I look like I need a companion? I'm using your product to lecture college students, they're engaged because I can flunk them, not because I'm using AI to do God-knows what.
The newest unpleasant surprise came when I logged into Freepik, an otherwise great site for finding license-free pictures. You search using various terms, they show you many, many pictures meeting your needs, and you download one or more. Fast, easy, user-friendly.
This time, when I selected a photo for downloading, a new screen popped up. Did I want to use AI to edit the picture? "Hmm," I thought. Or maybe said. I talk out loud a lot when I'm alone with the dogs. "I wonder if I could crop this guy out of an otherwise good image?"
Reader, I could not. The pinnacle of computing, the application that uses as much electricity as a small country and consumes an average of 550,000 gallons of water per day, per data center? Could stretch the photo side-to-side or up-and-down. And if you're thinking, as I did, "Hey, I can do that with MS Paint, a program first released in 1985," well, I guess you're not looking forward to the future. Or something.
I'm starting to feel like a diner in a restaurant that's bought way, way too much spinach and eggs. No matter what I ask for, the waiter keeps offering quiche. It doesn't seem as if these "improvements" have anything to do with, you know, what customers and users actually need.
Instead, I'm getting the sense that various CEOs, dazzled by the bullshit sales pitches, spent lots 'o money buying tickets on the AI train. In this metaphor, dear readers, we are tied to the tracks as the locomotive chugs toward us.
So, how do you feel about the plethora of AI assistants showing up online? Are you a fan? Or do you, like me, just want to scream, "Save me, Dudley Do-Right! Save me!"
Oh, I most definitely want to be saved from all those AI "assistants" who cannot wait to butt themselves into my business, whether I want them to or not. And I most definitely do not want their help/opinions/interference . . . .
ReplyDeleteNot a fan when it intrudes
ReplyDeleteNot a fan. I really dislike unnecessary "clutter" and I think much of the A-I stuff is clutter.
ReplyDeleteThe latest, most intrusive and annoying happens when I finish listening to a book on Audible. The most awful AI voice begins to tell me she is going to play samples of books like the one I just finished. First, no! Not now. I want to think about the book I just completed and write a review. Second, I want it off! I already have a lineup of books waiting. Third, I want quiet now. How can I shut it off? My hands are covered in (take your pick) batter, dough, soap suds, shredded zucchini, etc. Gak!
ReplyDeleteI have also been getting samples of similar books as I finish the current one. Did you realize this was because of AI.
DeleteMy husband had a fit over those sample books. Not being techie, he shoved the phone at me and told me to MAKE IT STOP!
DeleteIs there a way, Annette? It drives me crazy, too!
DeleteYes, Annette, can we make it stop? Help!
DeleteYes!! That is so annoyingly awful!! Maybe if no one buys those AI suggested samples, Audible with drop it??
DeleteI just finished listening to Stephen Fry narrate one of the HP books, which are now available in the US via Audible. A voice came on at the end and I thought it was how they ended the UK versions of the HP books. Apparently not…it was the AI voice mentioned above. How annoying. I need to figure out how to play my Audible books via the permanent copy I’ve downloaded to my computer instead of downloading the compressed version downloaded to my phone via their cloud. (Audible’s policies strongly recommend downloading a permanent copy of each of your audiobooks to your computer in case a book is dropped from their servers when their license ends.)
DeleteAs a troglodyte I have no use for AI, and AI as the coming thing doesn't bother me at all because I know that nothing can go wrong go wrong go wrong go wro...
ReplyDeleteWhen I tried to post the above, my computer told me, "I'm sorry Dave, I'm afraid I can't let you do that." When I yelled at the computer, saying, "My name is not Dave!", it said, "Sorry, my bad," and let me post the above.
DeleteJerry, too funny. Side note: a friend's dog, a Cardigan Corgi, is named Hal 2000.
DeleteOMG Jerry, mahalo for the laugh this morning *(desperately needed)!!
DeleteCackling, Jerry!
DeleteJerry, that wasn't Hal, it was Blogger, our special JRW AI.
DeleteI first noticed the unwanted AI feature on Meta (Facebook).
ReplyDeleteI suppose there is no way to turn this off?
I hate AI intrusion with a white hot passion. Get off my lawn, AI!!!
ReplyDeleteI am a hundred percent with you, Julia. It IS reminiscent of Clippy and seems to be everywhere! I, too, always scroll down past the AI summary when I do a google search. Will no one rid us of this meddlesome priest, I mean, pest?
ReplyDeleteI'm over AI. Sports Illustrated got caught using it to write articles with no attribution, using made up names instead. And when they got caught they acted like, "Who, me?"
ReplyDeleteThose AI summaries when I look up an article really tick me off. If I wanted a summary, I wouldn't have clicked on the article link in the first damn place.
TV shows using AI to create opening credits. Coca-Cola used AI to create their new holiday commercial and it's not going over well from what I've read.
I figure the rise of AI is not simply so Skynet can come about, but it is a plot to increase the ever increasing level of stupidity of the general populace. And it seems to be working.
With all this AI, where's Linda Hamilton when you really need her to put a bullet in the damn machine?
I completely agree with your theory about the ultimate purpose of AI to not only increase the level of stupidity among us mere humans but possibly obliterate whatever intelligence we have left. Sadly, many of the young people I know and work with are bamboozled by all things shiny and new and have not realized they are no longer using great portions of their brain any more. I will continue to relish in the memories of life pre-social media and AI and utilize as much of my brain in the “old fashioned” ways as much as possible.
DeleteNOT A FAN. "Save me, Dudley Do-Right! Save me!" I loathe those little AI chat bots on website pages everywhere. I don't understand them, don't want to, and will NOT engage with them. There. That should put AI in its place, right?
ReplyDeleteI'm with you 100%, Julia! It was over for me when I asked a question about someone's age. That shouldn't have been difficult but the answer I received, even based on the facts it presented, made no sense and I told it so. I got an apology for a reply after that but I was finished. I simply do not trust whatever they are coming up with.
ReplyDeleteI, too, have that stupid little assistant at my health insurance site. It has never been able to help me at so I no longer bother with it. But there it sits, and won't go away.
So funny Julia! Unfortunately, I don't think it's going away. Probably ever. I will say this about AI--it generates amazing headlines! Before my well-used brain can even begin...
ReplyDeleteFaith Lang
ReplyDeleteSo irritating! Several months ago when I opened the program with which I create a newsletter for my company, It asked if I wanted it to be created with AI! Just tell them what I want to say and they will do the writing. NO and NO and NO! *I* want to create, edit, and do it myself. There is joy in that. But it's here to stay.....sigh
I am with you completely, Julia! Google and Zoom are SO annoying. FB has little AI's attached to posts offering more information about this person or that concept. Spare me! A friend of mine turned on Zoom's AI companion thinking she would get a summary of her meeting. I can't remember what the meeting was about, but it included sharing personal information. What she got from AI horrified her. There's so much information about us out there being bought and sold every day so that we can receive "personalized" ads-- I really don't want to add to it by engaging with AI.
ReplyDeleteNot a fan of AI “enhancements” and I fear it will only get worse. Sigh
ReplyDeleteJulia, have you asked your students how they feel about AI? I'm curious.
ReplyDeleteI tried using the microphone to ‘type’ a text on the phone – those little buttons are so small and my fingers are not – and what came out was partly what I said, but mostly not. So I tried to go back and change idiot-things, and it gave me more idiot-things. I think this is AI, and if it is supposed to be a help, it isn’t.
ReplyDeleteToday’s irritating event is to try and figure out why we no longer have CBC radio 2. It disappeared mid-morning yesterday. Is it CBC, or a problem with the service from Bell (we get radio by satellite. Other tv channels seem to work.). I have no doubt that it will be a try and run through the AI robots to get to a real person, who will be probably be talking with me from ‘overseas’.
Margo, on some phones you can use the horizontal profile view to get a bigger keyboard. My brother-in-law could never type on his phone until I had him try that.
DeleteThanks, will try.
DeleteI always dictate texts and emails on my phone, and yes, I need to correct a few things. I suppose Autocorrect is AI but an earlier version of it. And it's been around for many years.
DeleteAutocorrect*^%%*#@! That devil will change the name of the person you are writing to without so much as a "Howdy-doo!" Reviewing your text, after pressing send, you find that the correct spelling of someone's name has been altered to look like a more popular spelling of that name. The other things it can change without you noticing will make you blush, stammer and apologize.
DeleteOn most phones you can turn autocorrect off.
DeleteI use a tablet to post comments. Canadian spelling is autocorrected to US spelling and it also incorrectly substitutes words in sentences. This only happens on Blogger posts. Not on blogs using WordPress or on FB LIVE. So weird.
DeleteDon't get me started on WordPress. Disappointment every time, erasing carefully thought out posts. Fooey.
DeleteFrom Celia: Apple doesn’t appear to be shoving ai at me but I agree it’s everywhere and I’m voting it off my island.
ReplyDeleteApple is in the process of rolling out AI, which they are calling Apple Intelligence, on to newer phones, iPads, and computers. They claim it will be less intrusive as they don’t collect user’s data.
DeleteWe kind of did this to ourselves, and starting back in the Clippy era, with autocorrect, autotype, and spell- and grammar check. All AI applications. The slope, she is slippery.
ReplyDeleteThe second time I noticed AI on Facebook was a few years ago, when instead of the image that was linked or copied in, there was a textbox saying "image of person shooting basketball". Remember that? Facial recognition is a feature of AI, too, and that was used a long time ago. Scarily. FB's search box has changed, too. It used to let you search for people from any of its search boxes; now it wants to search for goods, services, or businesses/webpages that have paid to be a search result. SO annoying.
I'm starting to think our politicians have been replaced by bots, by the way. Sigh.
Evil bots then, Karen….
DeleteSmall ways to avoid AI, do not use google for searches and do not do any searching on Facebook.
DeleteUse DuckDuck Go as your search engine. It is private.
Actually, I LOVE telling AI to go to hell. I always note that not only did I not summon it, but that I specifically asked that it NEVER communicate with me unless specifically summoned. And it apologizes.
ReplyDeleteAI doesn't bother me half as much as X's (formerly Twitter) deeply disturbing false information. And the tvnews makes me want to scream!
ReplyDeleteI solve that by never watching TV news unless a select few MSNBC shows.
DeleteWe are doing more of that now also Edith. We pretty much limit our news to NPR and our local newspaper. And 60 Minutes as long as it's not about he who should not be named.
DeleteQuit using X. Give Blue Sky.
DeleteWhat I think, Julia, is just as soon as you are finished with your current book, you need to collect this and many of your other posts into a book because we need all the laughter we can muster at this moment in time.
ReplyDeleteAI is the brainchild of the devil. Wasteful, unnecessary, lazy, and completely, utterly frustrating and untrustworthy.
I second that book of essays!
DeleteI agree! (Selden)
DeleteChiming in to say YES to a book of Julia's posts as essays, please!
DeleteYes yes yes, Julia!
DeleteYes to the essays!!
DeleteDebRo
This, too, shall pass. I hope. Even social media gives you summaries of comments. It's too much! May they all go the way of Clippy :)
ReplyDeleteAI and self-driving cars are horrors to me. Spelling and grammar checkers in Word are turned off. I know AI has done a lot of good in many areas but my current mood is so bleak I don't tolerate the little chat boxes and shut them down immediately.
ReplyDeleteThis morning to lift my spirits I have blasted Handel's Hallelujah Chorus. Wrong season but I need a little injection of joy and hope! (Selden)
I hear you, Jenn. It's vital to find the joy wherever we can these days.
DeleteFor a little cheer, check out Jon Batiste's new album, Beethoven Blues!! So fabulous.
DeleteOoo, Debs, Irwin will love that!
DeleteI laughed, Julia; thanks for expressing everyone's frustration so well. I think that this problem of pop-up AI messages must be worse in the US because I'm not so plagued by them. But I feel just like you do: no to all "helpful" suggestions that I don't request. AI's other problem for teachers, as I hear from my teacher and school principal friends here in Bern, is that kids use Chat GPT to write their essays. My friends say they catch the most egregious plagiarism examples but assume they're missing quite a lot of the abuse.
ReplyDeleteI am okay with the Google AI summaries, because sometimes I want a quick synopsis before I dive into the links. But the constant chatbots, "helpful" AI assistants, and what not? No thanks.
ReplyDeleteThey are about as useful as the constant reviews I get. "You visited the bank. How was your visit?" Well, I went to the ATM, got cash, and left, so I guess it was great.
The requests for reviews, Liz, too much!
DeleteHow do you review the aspirin you just bought? Is it good? Is it great?
It's the same stuff I bought last month. Just go away!
Judy, I think it’s more “I wouldn’t need the aspirin if you didn’t give me such a headache, AI”. — Pat S
DeleteI just replaced a blown head gasket on a mower engine. Briggs and Stratton wanted me to review the cardboard gasket! Then I repaired a broken tie rod on a different with a new ball joint and the repair warehouse wanted a review of the 1.5" ball joint. I understand the desire for reviews but it seems at a crazy level. (Selden)
DeletePat S. I am laughing. Selden, now I am laughing out loud. Talk about blowing a gasket!!
DeleteOh, gosh. I hated Clippy, or whatever that miserable annoying thing was. AI on my google summaries? Honestly, truly, I just ignore them. AI on Amazon reviews is fascinating--as long as it's about someone ELSES book. It seems terrifyingly reductive. But mostly I ignore the AI intrusions. Possibly I am being ostrichy, but as long as I know they are from AI a big IF) I let it all go.
ReplyDeleteDeb Romano
Delete(I don’t know what happened above.)
DeleteTrying to get rid of Clippy was an exercise in futility. I think our IT people eventually told us not to use it
DebRo
I’m with you, Hank. And have developed a new protective mechanism: just ignore it if it is making things worse and not better. Elisabeth
DeleteNone of our gripes begin to compare to the use of AI in creating propaganda on social media, but maybe we want to be ostrich-y today, la la la la....
ReplyDeleteHuh! So that is what all that extra crap on Facebook is. Still ignoring it.
ReplyDeleteI. Do. Not. Like. AI. “Assistants”.
ReplyDeleteDebRo
My personal IT person, aka my daughter has done something to block 95% of the Advertising online. This includes invasive AI. I like Gemini. Those of you who read my posts know that I am a poor speller and will often leave out words in sentences. So I have Gemini proofread my reviews before I post them. If the review is too homogenized, I bring it back to my voice. I also thought Gemini should learn about Zen. I asked a lot of questions. Eventually I was receiving more detailed information that was accurate. But Gemini they are fickle. Some days they do not know who Hank Phillipi Ryan is. Other days I get a lot of data. in a sense, AI is like a lot of people, one cannot trust them. The very old acronym GIGO (garbage in garbage out) still rules the world of 'puters.
ReplyDeleteDudley, save me! I am sick beyond words of these A/I helpers. Big reason why I never let Alexa in my house. Hubs claims A/I stands for artificial ignorance. He's not wrong.
ReplyDeleteYes! Alexa, et al, is more AI creep. Freaks me out when I'm at someone else's home and they suddenly ask Alexa to do something. Wait, it's been listening this whole time???
DeleteJULIA: Mixed feelings about AI. NO to AI altering photos or writing for you. NO to AI driving a car for you. NO to invasive AI. NO to AI making a hologram of the "perfect" you. I just read this amazing novel by Elle McNicoll (sp?), who wrote several YA novels including A KIND OF SPARK. I forgot the title of the other novel. The story was about an autistic son of a Tech Billionaire who owns an AI company. After the son is knocked down by a hit and run driver, he is taken to the hospital. And it looks like he is on the verge of dying. Meanwhile, his Dad's company creates a hologram of the son - a "better version" of the son WITHOUT autism and they also removed parts of his personality that made him unique. The hologram was saying things that the real person would Never say!
ReplyDeleteNeed to verify the new information that I recently learned about how AI helps to detect tumors. There is a new gadget where a deaf person can put on "eyeglasses" that will caption the dialogue for the wearer. If that is AI, then I am all for it! IF AI can be used to benefit humanity, then we have to decide what that is. That is another big question! For me, I would love to have these Hearview glasses that captions what everyone is saying!
What makes me crazy is that despite all the supposed smartness of AI when I ask google for GOOGLE DOCS it feeds me a bunch of links to sites that are NOT Google Documents but sites that use similar verbiage in their names and, I guess, pay for advertising. But wouldn't you think Google search engine would be smarter than feeding me those links first? As they say, Money money money money .... makes the search engines run. Which makes me ask: who is all this "smartness" servicing?
ReplyDelete